Death Cross Definition: How and When It Happens

12

What Does the Death Cross Tell You?

The death cross only tells you that price action has deteriorated over a period a little longer than two months, if the crossing is done by the 50-day moving average. (Moving averages exclude weekends and holidays when the market is closed.)45

Those convinced of the pattern's predictive power note the death cross preceded all the severe bear markets of the past century, including 1929, 1938, 1974, and 2008. That's an example of sample selection bias, expressed by using only the select data points helpful to the argued point. Cherry picking those bear-market years ignores the many more numerous occasions when the death cross signaled nothing worse than a market correction.6

According to Fundstrat research cited in Barron's, the S&P 500 index was higher a year after the death cross about two thirds of the time, averaging a gain of 6.3% over that span.7 That's well off the annualized gain of over 10% for the S&P 500 since 1926, but hardly a disaster in most instances.8

The track record of the death cross as a precursor of market gains is even more appealing over shorter time frames. Since 1971, the 22 instances in which the 50-day moving average of the Nasdaq Composite index fell below its 200-day moving average were followed by average returns of about 2.6% over the next month, 7.2% in three months and 12.4% six months after the death cross, roughly double the typical Nasdaq return over those time frames, according to Nautilus Research. The 23rd such occasion occurred in February 2022.1

Other recent surveys of returns following a death cross have also found a positive correlation with outperformance.2

Intuitively, the death cross has tended to provide a more useful bearish market timing signal when occurring after market losses of 20% or more, because downward momentum in weak markets can indicate deteriorating fundamentals. But its historical track record makes clear the death cross is a coincident indicator of market weakness rather than a leading one.6

Example of a Death Cross

Here is an example of a death cross on the S&P 500 in December of 2018:

It led to headlines describing "a stock market in tatters."9 The index proceeded to lose another 11% over the next two weeks and a day, The S&P then rallied 19% from that low in two months, and was 11% above its level at the time of the death cross less than six months later.10

Another S&P 500 death cross took place in March 2020 during the initial COVID-19 panic, and the S&P 500 went on to gain just over 50% in the next year.1

These examples don't represent the full range of possible outcomes after a death cross, of course. But they are at the very least more representative of current market conditions than earlier death cross occurrences.

Death Cross vs. Golden Cross

The opposite of the death cross is the so-called golden cross, when the short-term moving average of a stock or index moves above its longer-term moving average. Many investors view this pattern as a bullish indicator, even though the death cross was typically followed by the bigger gains in recent years.311

The golden cross can indicate a prolonged downtrend has run out of momentum.12

Limitations of Using the Death Cross

If market signals as simple as the interaction between the 50-day and the 200-day moving averages had predictive value, you would expect them to lose it quickly as market participants tried to take advantage.5 The death cross makes for snappy headlines but in recent years it has been a better signal of a short-term bottom in sentiment than of an onset of a bear market or recession.